It's an ATTACK ON THE CHURCH!!
Before you begin, let me just say that someone is going to tell you that this post is an attack on the church and that you shouldn't read it. They'll tell you this to have you dismiss anything that isn't in 100% full alignment with the perception that's put out by the Church. Everything is rosy and peachy-keen, and anyone who has any sort of criticism (especially Constructive Criticism) is jealous or of the devil, or wrong and that we should put a gag in their mouth (by pressuring them to stop bringing up topics, or ask them to leave the church) or put our fingers in our ears and ignore the truth and the easiest way to do that is to demonize the person challenging the issues.
God calls us to realize what is wrong in our lives and to straighten it out by using the Bible (
2TIMOTHY 3:16-17) which means that we first need to be able to recognize when something is wrong, not ignore problems but face them head-on and when problems become bigger than the person, the group, the pastor, to rely upon God and His word. This is all I ask. So view this if an attack if you disagree with all the points below. If you do not, however, consider these points as things that we need to be on the lookout for in all churches.
Who I am
I served as the Director of the Technology Ministry of a Southern Baptist Church in Maryland, was a member of the school board for their associated Christian School and privy to morning meetings in the pastors office during the week. I and my family were deeply involved in what was going on and consulted heavily on Church matters. God led us to leave the church 2 years ago, which wasn't easy, and wasn't understood by many friends as we were cautioned not to talk about church matters by the leadership so we couldn't explain why we were leaving. So we kept our mouths shut.
Since then a lot of people have imagined why... Demonized why.... But few know why... So as we begin to look to see if the church had changed enough to be suitable for our family, let's set the record straight on why God led us to leave and turn to God to see if He has an opportunity here to further our own growth.
Why did we join the Church?
When my eldest daughter reached the age of 9 years old I began to realize that as a parent a lot of our relationship was changing. It was no longer sufficent to just tell her not to do something and expect obedience. She needed to know WHY it was wrong to do things that we consider wrong and, more importantly she needed to know WHY it was important that she do things that we consider to be good. I turned to the faith that was instilled in me as a child. Although I hadn't been in church for many years I knew that one should not lie, cheat or steal, and I knew that because it had been incorporated into my conscience and that my conscience is derived from knowledge of God's law. I was a complete failure at passing along that conscience and knowledge to my oldest daughter and recognizing that I turned to the Lord and found a church in which we felt warmth and a lot of spiritual nourshment.
Finding the first love
Within months my wife, daughter and I found our first love, Jesus and became devoted followers of Christ. We studied our bibles, we prayed, we engaged in church activites and we embraced our callings. I was called to preach and evangelize and the Lord used me in a number of ways to meet His needs.
My yoke is easy, my burden is light?
In the months following however I and my family discovered that we were driven to many things out of shame and guilt that were difficult to reconcile against God's word. Whenever someone would call for extra nursery workers, for example, my wife felt tremendous guilt and left the service to go fill-in within the nursery, even though she'd already done so in the previous service. Months on end would go by where my wife heard not a single sermon preached because her guilt, and shame (on what others might think if she didn't go to the nursery) piled upon her back. Realizing the outward signs and impact of her missing service in her own life I insisted that she attend service and push through the feelings she had but she still felt guilt and shame for not leaving the service.
In my own ministry work I had become overwhelmed. The role of technology director had been handed off to me by a man leaving the church and in a 2000 member church there was a lot to be done. Those already in labor in that ministry I believe had a difficult time accepting new "leadership" that was more hands-on and driven to push the ministry further. In addition, the technology needs of the Christian school were going unmet and ill-managed and there was a great struggle in that area. Children in classes would receive pop-up advertisements for Victoria Secret ads, and the software to remediate that risk was not finding support on the budget. Access control to websites, and privacy settings were also unmanageable and there was no funding available to dedicate any resources to that need.
As leader of the technology ministry I was also put in charge of all of the church websites and PowerPoint presentations / graphic design for worship services. In all of these areas my commitment reached 20-30 hours per week and by the time Friday came it was difficult to find the motivation to go out on the street and evangelize. In short, our Yoke was breaking our backs and our spirits and the frustration of being in such a large body with so few "workers for the harvest" spurned resentment as my 3 children sat at home lonely for their father who was deeply under the plow driven into the ground by the weight of the yoke.
I was in real trouble.
Breaking Point
In 2008 I reached a breaking point, perhaps partly due to the work load and continuous fight, but I never found much that I could take to heart when those around me demonized me for doing the Lord's work. Where the struggle came from was on some issues of love, and issues of the law.
Those points for me were:
- Hypocrisy - While on the school board I became concerned over the hypocritical attitude of voting in a divorced man to be a member of the board while simultaneously dismissing a teacher for getting divorced. This didn't make biblical sense to me. How could we explain to the children that their teacher can no longer teach because of a divorce, but this new school board member (who ranks higher than the head master) is to be respected? This wasn't a commentary on the divorce issue, I have no skin in that game. It was a commentary about hypocrisy.
- School Board Profiting - While on the school board I became concerned when another school board member, was to personally profit from a fundraiser for the school. Fundraiser are great, but if people were to find out that school board members were filling their pockets from school fundraisers problems would arise. I met at length with both the School Board Member and the Senior Pastor. In the end the response was "we love the school board member, he's not trying to hurt us" and "we need the money". Both excellent points but the situation was both unethical and immoral. An pursasive argument needed to be reached that would demonstrate to those who would accuse this point as "evil" that it was in fact "good".
- Unwillingness to obey the Law - In my responsibilities as director of the Technology Ministry I was responsible for making sure web sites were done appropriately and to the letter of the law. The bible shows us that we must be respectful of the laws of our nation. Advice from legal counsel led to me setting a direction that:
1) No pictures may be taken of children without the permission of their parents.
2) Licensing information for songs must be displayed when they're lyrics are put up.
Common sense and minor things. As a parent I'm comforted by the fact that people won't be taking pictures of my kids without me knowing about it and the Licensing information on the screen was no matter, it's just a single line of text that says "CCLI ######" with the license number, no one would care right?
Wrong... Because of the requirement to gain parental consent, I was pulled into a meeting with the Senior Pastor, A Deacon, the church "photographer" and a few others where the photographer, practically foaming at the mouth and seething with anger accuses me of hatred toward the youth. I demonstrated email from lawyers at Christian Legal Protection showing WHY we need to do this and the risks of liability if we didn't. The Senior Pastor and I both tried to explain that the paperwork is the right thing to do, but I guess filling out a few extra pieces of paperwork is too much to ask to protect parental rights.
- Complete Lack of Oversight - In each of the incidents above I raised any concern I had to a pastor. The pastor would often setup a meeting with those involved. The issue would be discussed and in the end I, as part of the leadership, would be the one expected to capitulate on the issue out of love. Regarding the issues above the list below is generally what I was told:
- We don't want to hurt the school board members feelings, let him take the money, he'll give some to the school we're sure...
- We don't want to hurt the new school board members feelings, his divorce isn't the issue, we need people on the school board. (we needed teachers too)
- Regarding the photography issue, we don't want to upset the photographer, we want to love photographer (which to me in the new testament church I take to understand that if we love a person we help them to understand what the bible says, and love them to reach a solution that is in alignment with biblical teaching. Loving them and allowing a clear violation of the law that could put children and the church reputation at risk did not sit with me.)
- Threats made against me by Deacons - When I raised these issues I was told they did not matter by the deacons involved. When I tried to escalate these issues I was told the Deacons would not hear me and when I suggested bringing them up at the next Business meeting I was told by a Deacon at the time that I would be forcibly removed.
Let's PAUSE RIGHT THERE AMERICANS.... I was told that if I, as a member of the Church and leader of a ministry was to MENTION a topic during a business meeting that the Deacon would have me forcibly removed.
Following the Matthew 18 model I had a follow-up on this issue with the Senior Pastor and the deacon. And from that point my gag order stayed in place.
Enough time has passed for us to take another look at this church. This time, however, we're not going to do so in the shadows. The light should shine everywhere in God's kingdom and the truth shall be revealed, so as my family and I attempt to acclimate back into this church we will keep a log of what we see and experience.